Milk Kefir Eggnog

By : | 17 Comments | On : November 26, 2015 | Category : Fermentation, Kefir, Milk Kefir (MK), Probiotic, Recipes

Milk Kefir Eggnog

Milk Kefir Eggnog

I hunted the internet for a milk kefir eggnog recipe and couldn’t find one that was much more than adding a bit of kefir to homemade eggnog. I wanted a milk kefir that was flavored as an eggnog during the second ferment – so I came up with my own recipe.

I’m so glad I did, it turned out fantastic! The eggnog they sell at the store is way too sweet for me, and most brands contain corn syrup and unhealthy preservatives.

This milk kefir eggnog is thick and rich, just sweet enough, and full of probiotics.
I am already working on batch #2 – it’s delicious!

Milk Kefir Eggnog

Milk Kefir Eggnog Recipe

4 cups finished milk kefir (grains removed)
1/2 tsp. fresh grated gingerginger
1.5 tsp. vanilla extractvanilla extract
2″ cinnamon stickcinnamon sticks
1/8 tsp. ground clovesground cloves
1/8 tsp. allspiceallspice
3 cardamom podscardamom pods
3/4 cup 18% cream
1/4 cup + 1 tbsp. raw honeyraw honey (I used Nechako Honey)

Whisk to incorporate the honey and cover with a lid.

Ferment at room temperature for 24 – 48 hours (to taste – I waited 48 hours for the full probiotic benefits)

Strain to remove whole spices.

Separate 3 eggs. Whisk yolks until light and frothy.

Measure 1 cup of kefir mixture into a saucepan.

Add 1/8 tsp. nutmegnutmeg.

Heat slowly on medium-low heat, whisking continually.

When kefir is steaming (NOT boiling), add half of warmed kefir to egg yolks while quickly whisking yolks to prevent lumps.

Pour mixture back into the pot while whisking quickly.

Continue cooking at medium-low heat and whisking continually for about 15 minutes to produce a custard and to cook the eggs.
It will thicken up enough to coat the back of a spoon, or you can check for doneness by temperature; the eggs are cooked when the mixture reaches 160 degrees.

Remove from heat and allow custard to cool.

If you have any lumps, you can strain through a fine mesh sievefine mesh sieve.

Add custard into remaining milk kefir eggnog mixture, whisk to incorporate, and chill in the fridge at least 2 hours before serving.

Serve as is or add rum, bourbon, rye whiskey, brandy, Kahlua, or Grand Marnier.

Sprinkle with a dash of nutmeg to garnish.

Milk Kefir Eggnog

It is hard to wait for this to finish fermenting because once you put the vanilla and spices in the milk kefir, the aroma is incredible. Have you ever tried a milk kefir eggnog?

Share This Post!

Comments (17)

  1. posted by GrassFood on November 28, 2015

    Incredible! I can’t wait to try this. I’ve never done a second fermentation with my kefir. Thank you!

    • posted by YogurtHydro on November 28, 2015

      Come back and tell me what you think!

  2. posted by DJ on November 30, 2015

    I really need to try this. I need more probiotics in my diet.

  3. posted by alicia szemon on November 30, 2015

    eggnog! yass! i need to try this

  4. posted by Betty on December 6, 2015

    Thank you for sharing at the Thursday Favorite Things blog hop

  5. posted by Richard Hicks on December 14, 2015

    This would make a super drink when having guests over!

  6. posted by Karen on December 23, 2015

    Question! What would happen if you added the custard to the secondary ferment? Would it ferment as well? Thanks!

    • posted by YogurtHydro on December 30, 2015

      Sorry for the late reply – I took a week off for Christmas:)

      I wouldn’t add the custard to the second ferment because of the eggs. But once it’s all mixed together the kefir will continue to ferment the mixture in the fridge. The cold slows the fermentation, but it doesn’t stop it.:)

  7. posted by Lena P. on March 16, 2016

    Yum this sounds tasty. I’ll have to try it. I’ve never made my own kefir!

  8. posted by Samantha Sullon on March 21, 2016

    Sounds good to me! I will try this kind of eggnog :)

  9. posted by Debbie on December 30, 2016

    Doesn’t cooking kill the probiotics?

    • posted by YogurtHydro on January 5, 2017

      Yes it does; this is why I heat only 1 cup of kefir mixture in which to cook the egg as it leaves the remaining kefir unheated.:)

  10. posted by DivaDivine on November 20, 2019

    Just an FYI: eggs and nutmeg aren’t in the ingredient listing.

    Looks like a good recipe

  11. posted by Nancy on December 30, 2019

    Found this recipe for the holidays, and it’s a keeper! Just a note: I wanted to keep the probiotics intact, so I heatied just some milk with eggs and sugar, let it cool, then added the cooked custard to the second-ferment kefir that steeped in the cardamom, cinnamon and nutmeg. It still provides the thickening but without damaging the probiotics. Thanks for this treat!


Leave a Reply